Internal Control · 2024
In this section9 topics
- Internal Control — Board Opinion1 item
- Adequacy & Appropriateness of the Internal Control System1 item
- Internal Control Deficiencies1 item
- Audit Committee & Auditor Observations3 items
- Opinion on the Head of Internal Audit2 items
- Appointment, Discharge & Transfer of the Head of Internal Audit2 items
- Related Party Transactions1 item
- Counterparties & Transactions3 items
- Policy & Future Trends2 items
Internal Control — Board Opinion
Summary of the Board's Opinion on Internal Control
Internal Control
Opinion of the Board of Directors Regarding the Company’s Internal Control System
The company recognizes and values the importance of having a robust internal control system to ensure efficient operations. The company has established an adequate internal control system that covers all aspects to comply with relevant laws, regulations, and requirements. The Board of Directors has implemented effective mechanisms for monitoring and balancing to protect and maintain the company’s assets. This includes the delegation of authority (Delegation of Authority) to ensure proper checks and balances within both management and staff. The company has documented procedures and an independent internal audit department to oversee compliance with these procedures and report directly to the Audit Committee.
Additionally, the company and its subsidiaries have appropriate and sufficient internal control and internal audit systems in place to prevent potential fraud. These systems are clear, auditable, and aligned with the guidelines of the Stock Exchange of Thailand. During the Board of Directors meeting on November 11, 2021 (Meeting 5/2021), attended by all three Audit Committee members, the Board evaluated the internal control system by consulting with the company’s management and referring to internal control audit reports and follow-up reviews. The Board assessed the internal control system of the company and its subsidiaries in five areas based on the COSO framework (The Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission):
1.Control Environment
2.Risk Assessment
3.Control Activities
4.Information and Communication
5.Monitoring Activities
The Board of Directors believes that the company’s internal control and internal audit systems are adequate and appropriate. The company and its subsidiaries have sufficient personnel to effectively implement the system, including controls to monitor and manage operations, mitigate risks, and protect assets from improper or unauthorized use by directors or executives. The company also ensures sufficient measures are in place to manage transactions with potentially conflicting parties or related parties.
Furthermore, the Board has approved the assessment of the internal control system’s adequacy, which was developed in accordance with the Securities and Exchange Commission’s (SEC) internal control evaluation standards.
The company has also established an independent internal audit function that monitors and evaluates the internal control system by hiring an external auditing firm, I.A.P. Internal Audit Co., Ltd. (“IAP”), with Mr. Watthana Chanakin as the Managing Director and Head of Internal Audit. IAP began conducting internal control system assessments in 2020 with the objective of evaluating the adequacy of the internal control system and issuing audit reports. The Audit Committee reviewed Mr. Watthana Chanakin’s qualifications and deemed him suitable for this role due to his professional knowledge, independence, and over 17 years of experience in internal auditing. He has also completed relevant training, including the Internal Audit Certification Program (IACP) by the Thai Institute of Accountants and the COSO 2013 framework (Advanced Course). The company has a legal and secretarial department acting as a liaison between the external auditors and the company.
Adequacy & Appropriateness of the Internal Control System
Internal Control Framework Used
| Framework | Detail |
|---|---|
| The Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission (COSO) | The company recognizes and values the importance of having an effective internal control system to support the efficient operation of the company. The internal control system is sufficient and covers all aspects to comply with relevant laws, regulations, and guidelines. The Board of Directors ensures that there are effective mechanisms for monitoring and balancing to safeguard the assets of the group at all times. This includes establishing a clear delegation of authority to ensure proper checks and balances at both the executive and staff levels. The company has documented procedures and an independent internal audit department that ensures compliance with these procedures and reports directly to the Audit Committee. Moreover, the company and its subsidiaries have an appropriate and robust internal control and internal audit system in place to prevent fraud that may affect the group. These systems are clear, auditable, and aligned with the guidelines set by the Stock Exchange of Thailand. During the Board of Directors meeting on November 11, 2021 (Meeting 5/2021), which was attended by all three members of the Audit Committee, the Board evaluated the internal control system by consulting with the company’s management and referring to internal control audit reports and follow-up reviews. The Board assessed the internal control system of the company and its subsidiaries in five areas based on the COSO framework (The Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission), which includes: Control Environment Risk Assessment Control Activities Information and Communication Monitoring Activities The Board of Directors believes that the company’s internal control and internal audit systems are adequate and appropriate. The company and its subsidiaries have sufficient personnel to effectively implement the system, including controls to monitor and manage operations, mitigate risks, and protect the company and its subsidiaries' assets from misuse or unauthorized use by directors or executives, as well as from transactions with potentially conflicting or related parties. Additionally, the Board has approved the assessment of the adequacy of the company’s internal control system, which was developed in accordance with the internal control assessment standards of the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). |
Internal Control Deficiencies
Number of Deficiencies
| Metric | Current Year | Previous Year | Two Years Ago |
|---|---|---|---|
| Total number of internal control system deficiencies (cases) | 0 | 0 | 0 |
Audit Committee & Auditor Observations
Audit Committee's Opinion Differs from the Board's
No
Auditor Has Observations on Internal Control
Yes
Auditor's Observations
1. Observations from the Internal Audit Report for Q3/2024
1.1 The company has implemented a Purchase Request (PR) and Purchase Order (PO) system, but the report could not be tracked.
Later, in Q4/2024, the company improved the reporting system for PR and PO, and it is now trackable.
1.2 The company has established a Purchasing and Procurement Manual, which was implemented on January 1, 2020. However, the sequence of steps in the process is not appropriately structured.
2. Observations from the Internal Control System Evaluation – COSO 2013
2.1 The company should review and update its policies and the Operational Manual (COSO 2013) to reflect the current state. This review should be completed by Q1/2025.
Opinion on the Head of Internal Audit
Head of Internal Audit
3160
Audit Committee's Opinion on the Head of Internal Audit
Details about the Internal Audit Supervisor and the Supervisor for Monitoring the Company's Operations
The company has appointed I.A.P. Internal Audit Co., Ltd. ("IAP") as the internal auditor of the company, assigning Mr. Watthana Chanakinn, the Managing Director, as the primary person responsible for carrying out the duties of the internal auditor. He reports the results of the internal control system audit to the Audit Committee regularly. The Audit Committee has reviewed the qualifications of I.A.P. Internal Audit Co., Ltd. and Mr. Watthana Chanakinn and has concluded that they are suitably qualified to perform the duties, as they possess independence and extensive experience in internal auditing.
Appointment, Discharge & Transfer of the Head of Internal Audit
Requires Audit Committee Approval
Yes
Description
Internal Audit Supervisor of the Company
The company has appointed I.A.P. Internal Audit Co., Ltd. ("IAP") to perform the duties of the internal auditor of the company since 2020 to the present. IAP has assigned Mr. Watthana Chanakinn, the Managing Director, as the primary person responsible for carrying out the duties of the internal auditor for the company and its subsidiaries. In accordance with the authority, duties, and responsibilities of the Audit Committee, the Audit Committee has the authority to approve the consideration and appointment, removal, or transfer of the Internal Audit Supervisor or any department responsible for internal auditing, as well as approve the hiring of an external internal auditor. The Audit Committee also has the authority to set or adjust the compensation of the internal auditor to ensure that the department operates independently.
Related Party Transactions
Has Related Party Transactions
Yes
Counterparties & Transactions
Monetary Unit
1000000
Counterparties with Potential Conflicts
| Name | Person / Juristic Person | Nature of Relationship | As of Date (YYYY-MM-DD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mr. CHAIWAT KOVITCHINDACHAI | Person | he husband of Miss NIPHA APHIRATTANARUNGRUANG, who is a director and shareholder of the company, as well as the company's director and Chief Executive Officer. | 2024-12-31T00:00 |
| Miss NIPHA APHIRATTANARUNGRUANG | Person | The wife of Mr. CHAIWAT KOVITCHINDACHAI, who is a director, Chief Executive Officer, and shareholder of the company, as well as a director holding shares in the company. | 2024-12-31T00:00 |
| Ms. Salinthip Sukcharoenkraisri | Person | The younger sister of Mr. NATTHAPHONG SUKCHAROENKRAISRI, who is a director and shareholder of the company. | 2024-12-31T00:00 |
Transactions by Counterparty
| Transactions |
|---|
| 258.4 · Necessity: The company has borrowed money from Ms. Nipa Apirattanarungreung for working capital purposes under a loan agreement, with an interest rate of 4% per annum and 4.25% per annum. · Description: The company has borrowed money from Ms. Nipa Apirattanarungreung as follows: Bless Asset Group Public Company Limited Loan Amount Beginning balance: 286.40 Increase during the period: 16.00 Decrease during the period: (44.00) Ending balance: 258.40 Interest expense: -" · As of yesteryear: 155.0 · Nature of transaction: Loans from related parties · Audit committee opinion: This transaction is necessary, with reasonable terms and interest rates, and is intended for the benefit of the company's business operations. |
| 10.0 · Necessity: The financial institution issued a letter dated July 14, 2022, notifying the cancellation of the credit facility guarantees for Bless Asset Group Public Company Limited and Bless Asset Company Limited by Ms. Nipa Apirattanarungreung. The only remaining guarantee is for Bless Build Company Limited, where Ms. Nipa Apirattanarungreung continues to personally guarantee the credit facility with the financial institution for the company, in accordance with the terms set by the creditor. This guarantee is provided without any compensation. On August 22, 2024, the financial institution requested a guarantee for a short-term loan facility of 100 million baht for Bless Asset Group Public Company Limited by Ms. Nipa Apirattanarungreung, with repayment made on September 27, 2024. · Description: Ms. Nipa Apirattanarungreung has guaranteed the credit facilities of: Bless Asset Group Public Company Limited Total guaranteed amount: Remaining obligation: Bless Asset Company Limited Total guaranteed amount: Remaining obligation: Bless Build Company Limited Total guaranteed amount: 10.00 Remaining obligation: 10.00 · Nature of transaction: Guarantee for credit facilities from financial institutions · Audit committee opinion: This transaction is reasonable and serves the purpose of benefiting the company's business operations, as it is necessary to comply with the conditions for obtaining credit support from financial institutions for business purposes. |
| 0.0 · Necessity: On December 1, 2022, the company issued its first bond offering of 2022, with a term of 1 year and 9 months and an interest rate of 6.80% per annum, without collateral, to repay the bonds of series 1/2021, which were due for redemption on December 15, 2022. The company successfully issued bonds totaling 252.50 million baht. · Description: Bless Asset Group Public Company Limited Bonds Beginning balance Increase during the period Decrease during the period Ending balance Interest expense The company has paid interest on the aforementioned bonds. Accrued interest The company has accrued interest on the aforementioned bonds. · Nature of transaction: Ms. Nipa Apirattanarungreung has purchased bonds issued by the company. · Audit committee opinion: This transaction has the same terms and interest rates as those offered to other bondholders. It is considered a standard commercial term and is for the benefit of the company's business operations. |
Policy & Future Trends
Policy, Measures & Approval Process
Measures or procedures for approving related party transactions
In entering into related party transactions or interconnected transactions of the company and/or its subsidiaries, the company and/or its subsidiaries will comply with the Securities and Exchange Act, regulations, announcements, orders, and requirements of the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and the Stock Exchange of Thailand (SET), as well as follow the requirements related to the disclosure of related party transactions and other relevant criteria. Furthermore, individuals with an interest in the transaction will not be able to participate in the approval of such transactions. In cases where the law requires approval from the company's board of directors or a shareholders' meeting (as applicable) before entering into any transaction, the company will convene an audit committee meeting beforehand to consider and provide opinions on the necessity and reasonableness of the transaction, with careful consideration of the interests of shareholders and the company.
This applies to entering into ordinary business transactions or transactions supporting normal business activities that are subject to general commercial terms, as well as transactions that are not subject to general commercial terms, as outlined below:
1.Related Party Transactions with General Commercial Terms
Related party transactions or interconnected transactions with commercial terms that are similar to those that a reasonable person would negotiate with a general counterparty in the same situation, based on bargaining power free from influence due to their status as a director, executive, or related party (as applicable), and that do not result in the transfer of benefits. Furthermore, it can be demonstrated that the transaction terms or conditions are reasonable or fair, in accordance with the framework established by the board of directors, which has been approved as a principle by the board. In such cases, the management team is authorized to approve the transaction. The company will prepare a summary report of the transaction to be presented at the audit committee and board of directors meetings on a quarterly basis.
2.Related Party Transactions with Non-General Commercial Terms
Related party transactions or interconnected transactions that do not follow general commercial terms must be reviewed and commented on by the audit committee before being presented to the board of directors and/or the shareholders' meeting (as applicable) for further approval. The company will comply with the Securities and Exchange Act, regulations, announcements, orders, or requirements of the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and the Stock Exchange of Thailand (SET), including the requirements related to the disclosure of related party transactions and other relevant criteria.
In cases where the audit committee does not have the expertise to consider related party transactions, the company will appoint an independent expert, such as an auditor or an asset appraiser, to provide an opinion on the transaction. This opinion will be used by the audit committee, board of directors, and/or shareholders (as applicable) to support their decision-making, ensuring that the transaction is necessary and reasonable, with the company’s interests as a priority. The company will disclose related party transactions in its annual information disclosure form/annual report (Form 56-1 One Report) and the notes to the financial statements audited by the company’s auditor or in any other report (as applicable), in compliance with the relevant guidelines and laws.
Future Trends in Related Party Transactions
Future Trend or Policy for Related Party Transactions
In the case of future related party transactions or interconnected transactions, the company will set terms in accordance with normal business practices and market prices, which can be compared with terms or prices applicable to similar transactions conducted by the company or its subsidiaries (as applicable) with external parties. The company will have the audit committee provide opinions on pricing, compensation rates, as well as the necessity and appropriateness of the transaction. The board of directors will ensure compliance with the Securities and Exchange Act, regulations, announcements, orders, or requirements of the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and the Stock Exchange of Thailand (SET), as well as comply with disclosure requirements regarding related party transactions, the acquisition or disposal of assets by the company or its subsidiaries, and the disclosure of related party transactions in the notes to the audited financial statements.
These transactions will not result in the shifting or transfer of benefits for the company but will be conducted with the primary consideration of the best interests of the company and all shareholders. The approval process will follow the company’s delegation of authority guidelines or the operational guidelines of its subsidiaries (as applicable), and be reviewed by the relevant committees.
In the interim, before the policy takes effect, the company will present related party transactions for review and opinion by the audit committee before submitting the matter to the board of directors for approval. Directors with interests in the transaction will not participate in the meeting and will not have voting rights on the matter. The related party transaction policy will be effective from the date the company is listed on the Market for Alternative Investment (MAI) of the Stock Exchange of Thailand (SET).
For the current director loan transactions, the company has adopted a policy to reduce its financial reliance on related parties by ensuring no further loans to directors are made. The company will also gradually repay these loans according to a set plan. Additionally, after the company is allowed to offer shares to the public for the first time and becomes listed on the stock exchange, the company will have a stronger capital base and greater financial instruments and funding sources, such as issuing bonds or warrants. This will reduce the company's reliance on financial support from related parties as it has in the past.

